People talk
Our Guestbook
“ ube is the best flavor at this lil shop, also had creme brulee, pistachio, and amarula, would come back n try the chocolate which looks really creamy ”
“ My friend and I went for ice cream yesterday and loved it! The costumer service and atmosphere was great. I got three scoops caramel cookie crunch, cookie n cream and raspberry oats and red velvet cake. My absolute favorite was caramel cookie crunch, if you like caramel, you must try that flavor. My friend got two scoops cookies n cream and chocolate, as well as chocolate cake. 1010 recommend! ”
“ Always a treat to find grape nut on an ice cream menu thats a must order. This is richly flavorful ice cream in a cozy little storefront. Highly recommended. ”
“ The ube ice cream is truly so good! They offer a lot of unique flavors although the pints are a bit pricey. Overall, a favorite neighborhood spot. ”
“ Brown Butter Creamery is straight up awesome. The perfect place to go for a cold, refreshing, sweet scoop of gelato on a hot summer day. The staff were friendly and fast, the wait time was nonexistent, and my gelato was delicious and hit the spot. I definitely recommend the salted caramel crunch and the cookies and cream flavors! ”
“ Brilliant flavorful gelato with classical and a few unique flavors 12 with 4 vegan such as ube and lychee pear, decent portions and good prices 7.75 for 3 scoops and they allow sampling 2. They also have pastries, ample seating inside and outside and some merchandise. Will recommend. My favorite flavors were the lychee pear sorbet both fruits flavors come out great and it was really refreshing and the ube a lovely nutty vanillaish taste. The vegan raspberry oat was also quite good. The shop is women and black owned and they make the ice cream onsite. ”
“ Highly recommend! My favorite ice cream store in the country, no exaggeration. Today I tried the pumpkin pie, along with pistachio and chocolate. All were delicious. Will be back! ”
“ Apparently known for their gelato, but we had the key lime cheesecake and it was good! Really pleasant staff too! And they close at 9pm so great for late cravings! ”
Menu
Pint
$20.0012 Pint
$11.25Gelato And Cake Bundle
$22.00Banana Pudding
$8.50Cake Slices
$5.00
About
Brown Butter Creamery
Welcome to Brown Butter Creamery, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 375 Tompkins Ave. This artisanal ice cream shop is renowned for its commitment to crafting exceptional gelato and pastries using the freshest local ingredients combined with authentic imported Italian elements. Each batch of gelato is meticulously prepared onsite, ensuring a rich and creamy experience in every scoop.
When you step inside, the inviting atmosphere and friendly staff greet you, making it an ideal spot to indulge your sweet cravings on a warm day or to simply enjoy a cozy treat. As you explore their menu, prepare to be dazzled by a variety of unique flavors that are anything but ordinary. Customers rave about the ube and caramel cookie crunch, two standout flavors that represent the high quality and creative spirit of Brown Butter Creamery.
- Gelato – Available by the pint or in adventurous combinations, each flavor is a testament to their artisanal craft. From fresh local fruits to decadent imported ingredients, every bite is a delightful journey.
- Banana Pudding – Do not miss the creamy goodness of their banana pudding, which strikes the perfect balance of flavor with its homemade custard and ripe bananas.
- Cake Slices – Pair your gelato with a slice of their moist cakes for a harmonious dessert experience. Together, they create a gelato and cake bundle that’s priced at an irresistible value.
While the gelato is the star of the show, I must highlight the cozy ambiance and the customer service that makes every visit to Brown Butter Creamery a special occasion. Customers have expressed their delight not only with the delectable flavors but also with the welcoming vibe—making it a beloved neighborhood haunt. Each visit feels like catching up with an old friend, plus an opportunity to discover a new favorite flavor.
For anyone with a sweet tooth, this Brooklyn hotspot is a must-visit. Whether you’re savoring a scoop of creme brulee or diving into a decadent cake slice, Brown Butter Creamery is sure to make your dessert dreams come true. Don't forget to bring your friends along, as flavors like the salted caramel crunch and grape nut draw rave reviews that you won't want to miss out on!
Overall, Brown Butter Creamery represents a blend of creativity, quality, and local charm, making it a standout destination for both locals and visitors alike. Treat yourself to the blissful flavors that await you!
Book a table